Why is [spoiler info] please explain!!!

Discuss the anime series that started it all, .hack//SIGN and //LIMINALITY

Moderator: Moderators

who thought Tukasa was a guy

Poll ended at Mon May 02, 2005 3:18 pm

guy
1
9%
girl
10
91%
 
Total votes: 11

User avatar
Sora_TwinBlade
Posts: 5
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2005 11:52 am
Location: Collecting players memebers addresses

Why is [spoiler info] please explain!!!

Post by Sora_TwinBlade »

 why would they make him/her a girl!!! i mean i love the story line and all but why i thought he/she was a guy because didnt they say i mean didnt he/she say he was a guy!!! :? :? :? :? :? :? :?
User avatar
Helbaworshipper
The Golden Fleece
The Golden Fleece
Posts: 2734
Joined: Wed Jan 28, 2004 4:55 pm
Location: In the creator's chamber of the second epitaph.

Post by Helbaworshipper »

 her father always wanted a boy, so in the world she was a boy so she could forget about her father for awhile.
User avatar
[ EVA Kiss ]
Posts: 2
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2005 7:47 pm
Location: Tokyo, Japan
Contact:

Post by [ EVA Kiss ] »

Helbaworshipper wrote: her father always wanted a boy, so in the world she was a boy so she could forget about her father for awhile.
hmm.. interesting i always wondered bout that....
Suyo
Posts: 351
Joined: Tue Dec 28, 2004 10:48 pm

Post by Suyo »

 Tsukasa says he is a guy because eh think he is. because morganna deleted his memories...some of them...
General Wong
Posts: 6
Joined: Tue Mar 29, 2005 6:35 pm

Post by General Wong »

Thought it was a girl... Also thought it wasn't thát important.
User avatar
TsukasaKitty
Posts: 46
Joined: Fri Feb 18, 2005 11:05 am
Location: Net slums
Contact:

Post by TsukasaKitty »

The ending was way to obvious. I knew it before I saw the ending.

 Tsukasa wakes from her coma. She's the one who walks out the hospital. Her voice in her head is of a guy but her real voice is a girl.

If Tsukasa wasn't a  girl I wouldn't have taken the name.
User avatar
TsukasaKitty
Posts: 46
Joined: Fri Feb 18, 2005 11:05 am
Location: Net slums
Contact:

Re: Why is [spoiler info] please explain!!!

Post by TsukasaKitty »

Sora_TwinBlade wrote: why would they make him/her a girl!!! i mean i love the story line and all but why i thought he/she was a guy because didnt they say i mean didnt he/she say he was a guy!!! :? :? :? :? :? :? :?
Yeah but Tsukasa didn't know. I mean how would  shewith Morgana at control. Like anyone would  shesimply thought  shewas a  boybecause in the game  she looked like one. Wouldn't you?
User avatar
Stryke
Posts: 24
Joined: Sun May 08, 2005 8:40 am
Location: Logged into "The World".

Post by Stryke »

Thats a good point. I still think it was an awesome ending though, and I still use Tsukasa for my avatars and signatures, even if  Tsukasa was actually a girl.

Edit: Added spoiler tags. Please remember, even if you are posting something that you think could be spoiler information, use spoiler tags. Beowulf
User avatar
Kiru
Posts: 686
Joined: Fri May 20, 2005 7:41 pm
Location: making jokes about rape and aids.

Post by Kiru »

  Yeah ...Ann was her real name,right?
User avatar
ZKR
Posts: 59
Joined: Sat May 21, 2005 9:45 pm

Post by ZKR »

[ EVA Kiss ] wrote:
Helbaworshipper wrote: her father always wanted a boy, so in the world she was a boy so she could forget about her father for awhile.
hmm.. interesting i always wondered bout that....
wow, I never thought of that. I thought Morgonna did it simply because  she wanted to confuse Tsukasa and make her forget who she really was. I mean. Changing your whole gender, eesh.

As for the love story thing, well, that's life :roll:. Not everything works out how you want it to. I like this fact in .Hack//SIGN...it seemed more real to me that   Tsukasa turned out to be a girl, and Tsukasa and Subaru could only be intimate friends, rather than lovers. (though, I guess this could be argued, but we're assuming Subaru and Tsukasa are straight)

Plus, just go to any site where there are female and male avatars to choose from (ie: gaiaonline, RO, Maple Story). A lot of normal people choose to have  at least one avatar that is an opposite gender from themselves. For RP, looks, or otherwise :? [/spoiler]
User avatar
Twilight Wave
Posts: 90
Joined: Fri Jul 01, 2005 2:10 am
Location: Classified
Contact:

Post by Twilight Wave »

Lol...It was funny when Mimiru and Bear confronted him and they were like "Are you a girl" and Tsukasa was liek "Are you kidding" LOL twas funny.
User avatar
Bakuryukun
Posts: 41
Joined: Wed Mar 09, 2005 1:46 am

Post by Bakuryukun »

ZKR wrote:
[ EVA Kiss ] wrote:
Helbaworshipper wrote: her father always wanted a boy, so in the world she was a boy so she could forget about her father for awhile.
hmm.. interesting i always wondered bout that....
wow, I never thought of that. I thought Morgonna did it simply because  she wanted to confuse Tsukasa and make her forget who she really was. I mean. Changing your whole gender, eesh.

As for the love story thing, well, that's life :roll:. Not everything works out how you want it to. I like this fact in .Hack//SIGN...it seemed more real to me that   Tsukasa turned out to be a girl, and Tsukasa and Subaru could only be intimate friends, rather than lovers. (though, I guess this could be argued, but we're assuming Subaru and Tsukasa are straight)

Plus, just go to any site where there are female and male avatars to choose from (ie: gaiaonline, RO, Maple Story). A lot of normal people choose to have  at least one avatar that is an opposite gender from themselves. For RP, looks, or otherwise :? [/spoiler]
 I personally think Tsukasa and Subaru became lovers anyway....because there love had transended gender....hey it might be abit corny to some but the Tsukasa/Subaru coupling is just to cute for me to ignore :o
User avatar
S1lentOp
Posts: 1576
Joined: Sat Jun 04, 2005 8:35 pm

Post by S1lentOp »

Bakuryukun wrote:
ZKR wrote:
[ EVA Kiss ] wrote:
Helbaworshipper wrote: her father always wanted a boy, so in the world she was a boy so she could forget about her father for awhile.
hmm.. interesting i always wondered bout that....
wow, I never thought of that. I thought Morgonna did it simply because  she wanted to confuse Tsukasa and make her forget who she really was. I mean. Changing your whole gender, eesh.

As for the love story thing, well, that's life :roll:. Not everything works out how you want it to. I like this fact in .Hack//SIGN...it seemed more real to me that   Tsukasa turned out to be a girl, and Tsukasa and Subaru could only be intimate friends, rather than lovers. (though, I guess this could be argued, but we're assuming Subaru and Tsukasa are straight)

Plus, just go to any site where there are female and male avatars to choose from (ie: gaiaonline, RO, Maple Story). A lot of normal people choose to have  at least one avatar that is an opposite gender from themselves. For RP, looks, or otherwise :? [/spoiler]
 I personally think Tsukasa and Subaru became lovers anyway....because there love had transended gender....hey it might be abit corny to some but the Tsukasa/Subaru coupling is just to cute for me to ignore :o
I really doubt it.  Their relationship changed a lot after they found out he was really a girl. They became more friendly than intimate.
User avatar
Koryn
Posts: 23
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 7:20 pm
Location: Las Vegas

Post by Koryn »

lol, Elk should date Tsukasa
User avatar
Bakuryukun
Posts: 41
Joined: Wed Mar 09, 2005 1:46 am

Post by Bakuryukun »

S1lentOp wrote:
Bakuryukun wrote:
ZKR wrote:
[ EVA Kiss ] wrote:
Helbaworshipper wrote: her father always wanted a boy, so in the world she was a boy so she could forget about her father for awhile.
hmm.. interesting i always wondered bout that....
wow, I never thought of that. I thought Morgonna did it simply because  she wanted to confuse Tsukasa and make her forget who she really was. I mean. Changing your whole gender, eesh.

As for the love story thing, well, that's life :roll:. Not everything works out how you want it to. I like this fact in .Hack//SIGN...it seemed more real to me that   Tsukasa turned out to be a girl, and Tsukasa and Subaru could only be intimate friends, rather than lovers. (though, I guess this could be argued, but we're assuming Subaru and Tsukasa are straight)

Plus, just go to any site where there are female and male avatars to choose from (ie: gaiaonline, RO, Maple Story). A lot of normal people choose to have  at least one avatar that is an opposite gender from themselves. For RP, looks, or otherwise :? [/spoiler]
 I personally think Tsukasa and Subaru became lovers anyway....because there love had transended gender....hey it might be abit corny to some but the Tsukasa/Subaru coupling is just to cute for me to ignore :o
I really doubt it.  Their relationship changed a lot after they found out he was really a girl. They became more friendly than intimate.
I think they leave it open to interpretation so that the viewer can make their own decision on that topic...
User avatar
S1lentOp
Posts: 1576
Joined: Sat Jun 04, 2005 8:35 pm

Post by S1lentOp »

Bakuryukun wrote:I think they leave it open to interpretation so that the viewer can make their own decision on that topic...
Ya, but that doesn't mean that both interpretations are right.
User avatar
Twilight Wave
Posts: 90
Joined: Fri Jul 01, 2005 2:10 am
Location: Classified
Contact:

Post by Twilight Wave »

Well...it was answered right away...but it was cool when Tsukasa and subaru met in Real life.
User avatar
Bakuryukun
Posts: 41
Joined: Wed Mar 09, 2005 1:46 am

Post by Bakuryukun »

S1lentOp wrote:
Bakuryukun wrote:I think they leave it open to interpretation so that the viewer can make their own decision on that topic...
Ya, but that doesn't mean that both interpretations are right.
ummm...so what your saying...is that it IS left open for interpretation but....only one interpretation is right? :? that doesn't make sense at all....when something is left open for interpretation anyone can interpret it anyway they like....that's the point of being left open to interpretation.
User avatar
S1lentOp
Posts: 1576
Joined: Sat Jun 04, 2005 8:35 pm

Post by S1lentOp »

No, one interpretation would have to be right and the other wrong. It'd be like me saying "The heavens are infinite." You don't know what I mean, it's open to interpretation. It could mean sky, it could mean space, or it could be a heavenly paradise. There's interpretation. But when I say it, I mean space. And if the meaning of the word "heaven," in that sentence, is space, than it would mean that everyone who interpretted "heaven" as meaning sky or paradise is wrong. Get what I mean? Just because it's open to interpretation, doesn't necessarily mean all interpretations are correct.
User avatar
Bakuryukun
Posts: 41
Joined: Wed Mar 09, 2005 1:46 am

Post by Bakuryukun »

S1lentOp wrote:No, one interpretation would have to be right and the other wrong. It'd be like me saying "The heavens are infinite." You don't know what I mean, it's open to interpretation. It could mean sky, it could mean space, or it could be a heavenly paradise. There's interpretation. But when I say it, I mean space. And if the meaning of the word "heaven," in that sentence, is space, than it would mean that everyone who interpretted "heaven" as meaning sky or paradise is wrong. Get what I mean? Just because it's open to interpretation, doesn't necessarily mean all interpretations are correct.
yes but you see that wasn't truly left open to interpretation in the first place...because you already had something in mind....that's just not being specific or not using the right word for something.....not knowing what you mean by the word "heavens" is simply not knowing what you mean.....interpretation would be say if in a movie someone had a gun pointed to their head and then in the next scene it zooms out to the building your in and you hear a gunshot, now they have avoided showing you him actually getting shot and it becomes unclear if he ACTUALLY got shot or not, and it is left up to the viewer to decide for themselves....THAT would be something left up to interpretation....or in this case it's more along the lines of :  Tsukasa and Subaru's relationship is not in the end all that "defined" it doesn't say they got together...but then again it doesn't NOT say this either....besides if you don't like the idea of them getting togther....don't think they did, it's as simple as that....I personannly beleive they did and I'm sticking too that.
Post Reply