Anime vs super heros [Like DC and Marvel ]

Discuss new anime, old anime, upcoming anime series, fansubbed anime, etc

Moderator: Moderators

Which is better

Super Heros [dc or Marvel, please post the character ]
4
17%
Anime character[ please post the character ]
20
83%
 
Total votes: 24

User avatar
Cless
The Wandering Twin Blade
The Wandering Twin Blade
Posts: 1480
Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2005 1:45 am
Location: Kanawha, West Virginia

Post by Cless »

I wish Justice League wasn't on Toonami anymore. That's my wish.
Image
Slayn
Posts: 217
Joined: Thu Feb 23, 2006 12:56 pm

Post by Slayn »

DC characters are superheros of the real world. Modern time. The only animes you see that are real time nowadays are more along the lines of soap operas instead of duking it out with each other every second. And those don't tend to have people flying around waging war. Alot of animes you see go beyond just the living world. They have spirits, demons, alies, etc.. Fighting your own world where you are the exception to the weakness that is everyday people is different than fighting a completely different race of 'things' [i.e. aliens and demons].
Image
User avatar
Twilight Haseo
Posts: 153
Joined: Thu Jun 14, 2007 11:06 pm
Location: Arche Koeln
Contact:

Re:

Post by Twilight Haseo »

MasterKite wrote:Pffftt. Anime characters would totally win! Say you got Spiderman vs Inuyasha. Spiderman's gonna try to do this web crap and Inuyasha just gonna let loose the Wind Scar and beat the heck out of him. However I'm neutral on this for the most part because it matter which anime character vs which super hero. Cheesy super heros like Superman would win against pretty much every character because of his multiple powers and immunity to everything except kryptonite.
Except, Super Saiyajin level 4 Gogeta. Hell, even Super Saiyajin level 1 Goku could whoop that Krypton senseless. :D

However..he'd lose against the Living Tribunal. Like someone stated before, it depends on what anime character's paired up against what comic book character, hm.
Image

"And then there was one." ~Twilight Haseo
User avatar
lukan
Author of "Black And White And..."
Author of "Black And White And..."
Posts: 1757
Joined: Mon Nov 20, 2006 8:56 pm
Location: Land of Prinnies, DOOD!!! Now with more pancakes!!(member of the Rotton Peaches)

Re: Anime vs super heros [Like DC and Marvel ]

Post by lukan »

Flash: Well, he'd be hard to hit, but Dbz charas would keep up(Notice a theme?)
DC characters are superheros of the real world. Modern time.
I'll give you one fighting anime off the top of my head:
Negima.
er....vol, 12 was it?no, 13.
The characters are fighting a huge tourney and even normal people with extreme training can stand up to the 'super' characters for a bit.
One of the girls in the audience even says around the end "I've watched this thing since the beginning and my eyes are getting used to the speed already!"

>_>
Toszi
Newbie manga! "Black And White And..."
dr-toszi.deviantart.com
User avatar
.khun
Posts: 390
Joined: Sat Jun 16, 2007 11:16 pm
Location: a university, graving to survive in this city

Re: Anime vs super heros [Like DC and Marvel ]

Post by .khun »

since anime is all around the world of course they will pick ANIME!!!
Image
User avatar
Hyuuga
Posts: 476
Joined: Fri Apr 06, 2007 9:10 pm
Location: Mao tau ajah dimana xP

Re: Anime vs super heros [Like DC and Marvel ]

Post by Hyuuga »

My official vote goes for Anime. For somewhat reason, i've found that anime is much more interesting and got great music. For the superheroes, Batman is the best, i think...
Image
Click teh Sig :D
oslapedo wrote: Well imo you win for bitchiest forum poster =/
User avatar
Fallen Guardion
Posts: 166
Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 12:22 am
Location: Chained to the misery that is reality

Re: Anime vs super heros [Like DC and Marvel ]

Post by Fallen Guardion »

Like many have said before, it depends on whom is being compared to whom.
For instance, obviously Batman would be no match for DBZ characters, due to their insane "power" and near invunerablity.
However, DBZ Vs. The Phoenix, or a fully powered Franklin Richards is not going to go well for the DBZ boys.
There are many "superheroes" who defy and manipulate the laws of physics and reality.
Hell, Franklin could simply will the universe to expel the DBZ boys.
And the Phoenix is overtly immortal. Hell, the Phoenix Force is Life itself.
That is a ridiculously overpowered individual, to the likes that most cannot begin to stand against.

So, really, the question isn't so simply which genre will win, as both have powerful, "god-like" entities.
It's really character vs. character.
Even then, however, there are circumstances that may change depending on where they are.
We all need to remember, that the characters we vote for are only powerful in their own "story-world".
For all we know, Goku could be killed by a butterfly in Spiderman's world. And vice-a-verse-a.

However, my vote would have to go to Squirrel Girl. :lol:
Look it up, you'll understand! :D
We are free to sever the Chains of Fate that bind us...Though this too may be our Destiny.
User avatar
lukan
Author of "Black And White And..."
Author of "Black And White And..."
Posts: 1757
Joined: Mon Nov 20, 2006 8:56 pm
Location: Land of Prinnies, DOOD!!! Now with more pancakes!!(member of the Rotton Peaches)

Re: Anime vs super heros [Like DC and Marvel ]

Post by lukan »

....instead of keeping 1-1....
let's think in terms of a COMPLETE battle royale

>_>
Toszi
Newbie manga! "Black And White And..."
dr-toszi.deviantart.com
User avatar
marthwmaster
The Fullglass Optimist
The Fullglass Optimist
Posts: 1405
Joined: Wed Apr 12, 2006 4:29 pm
Location: to the east of west

Re: Anime vs super heros [Like DC and Marvel ]

Post by marthwmaster »

I'm kind of confused by the poll. Are you asking if anime is better than DC or Marvel? That's kind of one-sided, don't you think? You're comparing two comics publishers to the entire anime industry, and as has been stated earlier in this thread, Eastern and Western animation inspire each other. That's just how it works: American comic writers obsessed with Japanese cartoons are naturally going to be inspired by them, and vice versa. Now, I've never been particularly interested in superhero culture, but I'm assuming you didn't mean to compare DC & Marvel to all of anime. So, being insanely fond of Heroes, I picked superhero over anime, because I think I might like Claire just a TINY BIT MORE than Cassandra. It's close as hell though.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ :Cassandra Alexandra
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- : Claire Bennet
User avatar
haseo1250
Posts: 27
Joined: Tue Jul 31, 2007 2:24 am
Location: In One Of The Lost Grounds

Re: Anime vs super heros [Like DC and Marvel ]

Post by haseo1250 »

Soubi and Ritsuka from LOVELESS will kick anone's ass
*~TO BE FORGOTTEN IS WORSE THAN DEATH~*
*~LOVE IS LIKE HATE EXCEPT SOMEONE
GETS CANDY~*
User avatar
silabus
Posts: 1225
Joined: Sat Dec 09, 2006 12:06 pm
Location: Hidden Forbidden Trilogy Film

Re: Anime vs super heros [Like DC and Marvel ]

Post by silabus »

Goku and Naruto will pwn everybody ass
Image

So be it.
Post Reply