Tron wrote:Well. I suppose you're right.
However at this point I quite like SIGN and appreciate it for what it is.
There's one piece of .hack// anime I outright despise though and that's ROOTS.
I mean, when I played GU, the way Haseo acted in regards to Shino, I imagined his times with the Brigade being different.
But no. All of their relationships were weird and... I dunno. They kinda killed for me everything the games established.
Plus, they clearly tried to do another SIGN with ROOTS, but it just doesn't work. There's too much of a tone incositency with the games. Had I seen this before playing the games... maybe I would have liked it a bit better? But in general though, ROOTS is just... ugh.
But I digress.
Having seen //ROOTS before playing the games, I still didn't quite care for it nearly as much as //SIGN, I like what they *tried* to do with it, seeing Yata and Pi scheming that early on was fun, but I do agree that something in the tone seems... off. There's some select great moments, I enjoy the actual hunt for the Key of the Twilight. Shino implying that she and Ovan know what Haseo does for a living (which Haseo doesn't really seem to catch onto) and Shino's increasing desperation to find Ovan after he goes missing, (which ties in very well to the end of Redemption. "Hey, thanks for saving me, let's go find Ovan!")
As for characters I really like Tawaraya/Touta and was a bit upset that he was never referenced in the games at all since he was a really fun character at least Phyllo was given some mention in the games. I don't care much for the second half of //Roots after Shino is attacked by Tri-Edge though. I liked the Labyrinth and the Harald mention but everything seems to slow down from there.