Poll Debate: Shakugan no Shana Vs. Rurouni Kenshin

[Carnage]

hmm... how bout ichigo vs kenshin >_>

hmm Ichigo? um not sure, seems kind of unfair. Especially if it's Bankai Ichigo. And besides hes a Shinigami (representative). Human spirit or not, he's not a normal human.

[DotHack-Haseo]

hhhmmmmmm.........What about Inuyasha vs. Kenshin?

[Carnage]

lol um isn't Inuyasha a half-demon?

Something more believable like um Kenshin vs. Jin/Mugen or something, just an example.

[DotHack-Haseo]

Even still.....Inuyasha vs. Kenshin would be an even match I think..........just because Inuyasha has the tesutsaiga doesn't mean that he's gonna win.

Kenshin and Inuyasha are pretty much equal in speed............In the strength department....Inuyasha wins.........but that doesn't mean that Inuyasha would win. As long as they don't clash swords it would be an even match. Because All Kenshin would have to do is Bludgin Inuyasha's arms until they can't weild the Tetsutsaiga anymore and then all inuyasha would have is his claws and his sheith. But Even then He wouldnt be able to use his claws.

Without his sword....Inuyasha is N-O-T-H-I-N-G!!!!!

[Carnage]

Even still.....Inuyasha vs. Kenshin would be an even match I think..........just because Inuyasha has the tesutsaiga doesn't mean that he's gonna win.

Kenshin and Inuyasha are pretty much equal in speed............In the strength department....Inuyasha wins.........but that doesn't mean that Inuyasha would win. As long as they don't clash swords it would be an even match. Because All Kenshin would have to do is Bludgin Inuyasha's arms until they can't weild the Tetsutsaiga anymore and then all inuyasha would have is his claws and his sheith. But Even then He wouldnt be able to use his claws.

Without his sword....Inuyasha is N-O-T-H-I-N-G!!!!!

Well he isn't totally nothing, you remember about him turning into a full demon when he doesn't have his sword.

And I never said about who would win, I only meant it would be a more believable fight, if Kenshin were to fight another human with similiar skills, other then demons, shinigamis and whatnot.

[Vahn Staffear]

lol um isn't Inuyasha a half-demon?

Something more believable like um Kenshin vs. Jin/Mugen or something, just an example.

Kenshin vs. Jin/Mugen=Jin/Mugen

Mugen's style is unheard of therefore unpredictable to Kenshin who might have never seen his style before, knowing Kenshin he would pull a Karuma and wait ou the fight untill he can collect enough information on Mugen.

[DotHack-Haseo]

I guess that's what Kenshin would do or Kenshin would just run around until Jin/Mugen exhausted themselves by swingin their sword around then Kenshin would go in for the Kill.

[Carnage]

I guess that's what Kenshin would do or Kenshin would just run around until Jin/Mugen exhausted themselves by swingin their sword around then Kenshin would go in for the Kill.

If you've seen Mugen, you would know that he has more stamina then you think. He could be cracked in the skull bleeding, then kicked in the balls, and still be fighting like he would normally(which actually did happen once). And like Vahn said, his moves are unpredictable, and he doesn't just use the sword but in combination with his legs to attack also. I mean your talking like Kenshin has more stamina then Mugen does, and your also saying that Kenshin wouldn't get exhausted either. I think it would be a even match.

I think we should stop this now, seening as how this is going, no matter the matchup, your just going to come up with w/e logic you think how Kenshin would win, when Kenshin himself may or may not do that.

[DotHack-Haseo]

We could stop the match-ups but....wheres the fun in that?

Any way...Kenshin does not have infinite stamina...I know this.

Any way.....I am a shana fan.........but in the meantime..lets have nice friendly conversations about the shows. What you think is better and so forth and such width.

[Red Frost]

I've never heard of the other show... But I love Kenshin, and I miss the show. Nobuhiro Watsuki is an awesome artist. And, well it's been so long since I've seen the show... But I remember loving it.

I never got to see all the episodes, especially the Shishio ones. I had to wait for the Manga to see how it ends.
What happened to the show?

[DotHack-Haseo]

They took it off Cartoon Network about a year back....it was on Anime Network on Demand for a little while but other than that I don't know.

But At suncoast......The have the entire Box set of the whole show for sale for $99.97, I was gonna buy it but I had already budgeted for my new XBOX 360 hard drive....so I was kinda boned in that department.

[Vahn Staffear]

I guess that's what Kenshin would do or Kenshin would just run around until Jin/Mugen exhausted themselves by swingin their sword around then Kenshin would go in for the Kill.

If you've seen Mugen, you would know that he has more stamina then you think. He could be cracked in the skull bleeding, then kicked in the balls, and still be fighting like he would normally(which actually did happen once). And like Vahn said, his moves are unpredictable, and he doesn't just use the sword but in combination with his legs to attack also. I mean your talking like Kenshin has more stamina then Mugen does, and your also saying that Kenshin wouldn't get exhausted either. I think it would be a even match.

I think we should stop this now, seening as how this is going, no matter the matchup, your just going to come up with w/e logic you think how Kenshin would win, when Kenshin himself may or may not do that.

And Vahn pwns again.

[DotHack-Haseo]

Carnage wrote:

DotHack-Haseo wrote:
I guess that's what Kenshin would do or Kenshin would just run around until Jin/Mugen exhausted themselves by swingin their sword around then Kenshin would go in for the Kill.

If you've seen Mugen, you would know that he has more stamina then you think. He could be cracked in the skull bleeding, then kicked in the balls, and still be fighting like he would normally(which actually did happen once). And like Vahn said, his moves are unpredictable, and he doesn't just use the sword but in combination with his legs to attack also. I mean your talking like Kenshin has more stamina then Mugen does, and your also saying that Kenshin wouldn't get exhausted either. I think it would be a even match.

I think we should stop this now, seening as how this is going, no matter the matchup, your just going to come up with w/e logic you think how Kenshin would win, when Kenshin himself may or may not do that.
And Vahn pwns again.

And DotHack-Haseo fails to enthral the masses.

in the meantime Vahn is sipping on a Pina Collada.

Vahn: Life is Good

DotHack-Haseo: Life Sucks

[Vahn Staffear]

Carnage wrote:

DotHack-Haseo wrote:
I guess that's what Kenshin would do or Kenshin would just run around until Jin/Mugen exhausted themselves by swingin their sword around then Kenshin would go in for the Kill.

If you've seen Mugen, you would know that he has more stamina then you think. He could be cracked in the skull bleeding, then kicked in the balls, and still be fighting like he would normally(which actually did happen once). And like Vahn said, his moves are unpredictable, and he doesn't just use the sword but in combination with his legs to attack also. I mean your talking like Kenshin has more stamina then Mugen does, and your also saying that Kenshin wouldn't get exhausted either. I think it would be a even match.

I think we should stop this now, seening as how this is going, no matter the matchup, your just going to come up with w/e logic you think how Kenshin would win, when Kenshin himself may or may not do that.
And Vahn pwns again.

And DotHack-Haseo fails to enthral the masses.

in the meantime Vahn is sipping on a Pina Collada.

Vahn: Life is Good

DotHack-Haseo: Life Sucks

Couldn't said it better my self.

[DotHack-Haseo]

Hahahaha...lol.


any way....shana would win against kenshin no doubt...that's what i think....Although..shana is still going in terms of american dubbing.....but so far the show is kicking off.

Kenshin was a good show with cool points in the story all around...but I pretty much think a couple of the Kenshin movies killed. As far as I know there are 3 Kenshin movies?

Any way theres mt two cents.

[DotHack-Haseo's Brother]

I haven't really seen shakugan no shana, but I think rurouni kenshin is the best.....If I had to say, I would think that Kenshin would walk all over Shana.

Anyway, I know for a fact that Kenshin could not beat a gundam. It is just, scientifically impossible...even if it is an anime.

[Carnage]

I haven't really seen shakugan no shana, but I think rurouni kenshin is the best.....If I had to say, I would think that Kenshin would walk all over Shana.

Anyway, I know for a fact that Kenshin could not beat a gundam. It is just, scientifically impossible...even if it is an anime.

You know you should really give us an explanation on why you think Kenshin would beat Shana, other then just saying Kenshin. Beening the fact that you haven't even watched Shana as bolded above.

An example would be if someone who has not seen any Gundam before, but has seen Kenshin. That person would probably say Kenshin would "walk all over" a Gundam, which is just like your situation here.

[DotHack-Haseo]

Come on Bro.....think before you post. I am going to make you sit down and watch Shana Tomorrow and I don't want to hear you bit**.

Anyway, family squabbles aside, I agree with you that if you've never seen the show then how in the hell are you going to know who can beat who?

But in the meantime........I'm going to take a shower now and will probably be back on in a few.

[-Soba Ni-]

carnage i notice you keep siding with the side that opposes kenshin(am i making sense?). do you hate him or something?

anyway, do any of you remember the KenshinXSoujiro match? yep, you couldn't see kenshin in the final showdown. having that said, i have shown an estimate of kenshin's full speed.

as for a gundam, i have to admit they are fast. but fast and huge don't go well together. i can't disprove the fact that a gundam can pwn kenshin though.

as for ichigo, his speed can match up to kenshin's if he is in Bankai/hollow or Bankai AND hollow form. after that it's a measure of who gets the first major hit in.

as for Jin/Mugen, it has been highlighted in one of the Rurouni Kenshin episodes that yes, Kenshin reads your style of fighting and decides on a winning plan. but somewhere during the series, when Kenshin was being re-taught by Hiko, Hiko highlighted that fact and got Kenshin to stop doing that. after that, Kenshin acts as the situation deems fit instead of reading his opponents movements. having said that, Jin/Mugen VS Kenshin would be a matter of Last Man Standing. True, Mugen has a great deal of stamina, but so does Kenshin as seen in the Shishio battle despite being repeatedly wounded by Shishio. If Kenshin reverses his Reverse-edged blade, it would be cake since he would slice with every hit, but Kenshin won't do that so it's last man standing or draw. if anyone of them gets distracted it's good game.

i haven't watched shana, but i'll catch it, no worries

as for more matchups, i would like to see
Kenshin VS Mido Ban
Naruto VS Ichigo
Sasuke VS Ichigo
Sasuke VS Kenshin
Ichigo VS Jin/Mugen
Naruto VS Mido Ban
Sanosuke VS Mido Ban (no sword, no jagan)
Gundam(let's say.... the new Freedom) VS Naruto xD
Dr Jackal VS Kenshin
Fuyuki Shido VS Sanosuke
Tasuki VS Shishio
Chichiri VS Amano Ginji
Inu Yasha VS Orochimaru
Soujiro VS Kuchiki Byakuya (rofl)
Cho Hakkai VS Chichiri
Evangelion VS Gundam

ignore those matchups, i'm just being crazy xP

[DotHack-Haseo]

I wouldn't mind seeing that Inuyasha vs. Orochimaru fight.

That would be a damn good fight. I wonder............Could inuyasha use wind scar in that fight??????????

wait yeah he can :p, he can use the wind scar whenever he wants.

This would be a very good fight.