Avatar And Signature Rating Topic

[Astra]

@Daichi: it's actually not a C4D. i made all the background effects from scratch, by hand. there's no C4Ds in that sig whatsoever.

@-loveless-:

sig: kinda small, i don't know how to rate it. it's small...the text is...ok...the focals are too big for the canvas size, and the effects take away too much from the render / render. 6/10

avi: 6/10 same as above.

--------------------------------------

to reiterate. i DON'T want a 10/10 on this sig...i want something less, and LOTS of negative feedback for improving.

don't rate my currents, just the Saber one below.

[Saya]

Now lets see here...

Mellow: 3/10 The red is overbearing and throws the sig off balance and theirs no render blending just a slap on job and the background is kinda monotone as well suggestions try blending the render with grad maps and different modes as well and don't take this the wrong way but read some tuts on another sites to see how they blend their renders and add effects without to much distraction plus the text is kinda meh.

Ohh that thing at the bottom of astras avatar is a clipping mask its a effect thats all.

daichi: You improved since I saw you last time but you gotta work on blending on the render and getting a good flow on your C4Ds you can add me to YIM and I can do the same thing I did to astra I trained him myself and he gotten way better but be warned.....I'm not that easy you know keep it up dude.

Astra: Like in the club I love the flow of your sig but the text is kinda iffy to me 9/10 you came a long way when I taught you and look at you now I'm proud to see you grown so much.

[Daichi]

Now lets see here...


daichi: You improved since I saw you last time but you gotta work on blending on the render and getting a good flow on your C4Ds you can add me to YIM and I can do the same thing I did to astra I trained him myself and he gotten way better but be warned.....I'm not that easy you know keep it up dude.

Astra: Like in the club I love the flow of your sig but the text is kinda iffy to me 9/10 you came a long way when I taught you and look at you now I'm proud to see you grown so much.

well.... you aer the most kind... (live in DK, so i don't think the AIM is possible, though....)

your sig is.... messy. and i like that!

avy is good too!

10/10

[Haseo{Terror of Death}]

Now lets see here...

Mellow: 3/10 The red is overbearing and throws the sig off balance and theirs no render blending just a slap on job and the background is kinda monotone as well suggestions try blending the render with grad maps and different modes as well and don't take this the wrong way but read some tuts on another sites to see how they blend their renders and add effects without to much distraction plus the text is kinda meh.

Ohh that thing at the bottom of astras avatar is a clipping mask its a effect thats all.

daichi: You improved since I saw you last time but you gotta work on blending on the render and getting a good flow on your C4Ds you can add me to YIM and I can do the same thing I did to astra I trained him myself and he gotten way better but be warned.....I'm not that easy you know keep it up dude.

Astra: Like in the club I love the flow of your sig but the text is kinda iffy to me 9/10 you came a long way when I taught you and look at you now I'm proud to see you grown so much.

@Saya: HOLY CRAP, THEY ROCK, 11/10

[Balmung2]

Balmung2

sig: 5/10 - aside from having no flow, the C4D? in the background isn't blended correctly to go with the sig. Both the focals of the sig are poorly place, i recommend the center, which in your sig, is just boring blank space. i don't like the messy 'fractal' look to it, with the random lower-opacity C4D stuck in there. Although Balmung is blended, i feel not enough.

avi: 6/10 - the checkered effect looks interesting, but like Daichi's it's a tad boring, and doesn't attract too much attention.

Thanks for the criticism. That's what I look for when I come here, not "hmm it's ok" or something like that. We may not agree on everything (;p) but I'm glad you actually critiqued some of us...Oh, and on the avatar, it's a character's icon...It's a tad small, so it may not be as aparant, though I understand about the bland part.

Can you give me a good place to get c4d from, because honestly, everything I make I've done from scratch (except renders...usually -_-), and I need to start incorporating some c4d.

ToD
Avatar: Meh. Just Meh. If you drew that, then it's really nice, but just resized with some misplaced text. If it's not drawn, then it's slightly blurry (still is if drawn xp), and not that impressive. Boring. 4/10

Sig: I like the colors, but again, it's so bland. I like the approach, but a little bit more substance would be nice. And the text is a bit obnoxious, especially on the name part. 4/10

[Daichi]

Can you give me a good place to get c4d from, because honestly, everything I make I've done from scratch (except renders...usually -_-), and I need to start incorporating some c4d.

deviantart.com




my new sig. experimental with clipping mask

[Adept]

I'll give those new sigs 9/10 I like .Hack

[-Loveless-]

I like the Avatar 9/10 and I like the signature, but a tad bit blurry on my end, so 7/10. <3

[Adept]

Loveless

Avi: 7/10 scares me...
Sig: 9/10 Inuyasha rules!

[Daichi]

adept, sorry, bot i can only guess who are on the "sigs" here...

too grainy, BAAAAAD font, and ... try use "the GIMP" instead of mybannermaker... that'll help a lot

00/10

avy: this is cool... 10/10

[Adept]

adept, sorry, bot i can only guess who are on the "sigs" here...

too grainy, BAAAAAD font, and ... try use "the GIMP" instead of mybannermaker... that'll help a lot

00/10

avy: this is cool... 10/10

Yeah I know they suck only cause I don't have a better sig maker at the time I'm getting one soon hopefully once I get my own comp. The one I'm using is the family one. I'm getting ride of the ones I asked to be rated. I'll post the new ones when I get it to work. Till then plz just rate the one i'm using. Downloading GIMP as we speak. Thanks Daichi for the suggestion.

[Arukado]

Hmm..lesseee...Daichi. P:

Sig - 5/10
Avatar - 9/10
The sig seems a little..clustered. I like the avatar, though. :3

[Haseo{Terror of Death}]

AruKado
Avi=7/10, it's really nice, but it's not SO eyeappealing
Siggy=there is none

[Daichi]

thats a nise sctech, and nice text. text blends good...

6/10



some sig in the request thread i made

i tried my new CS3... im not realy fammiliar with it...

judge yourself:

[The*true*Terror Of Death]

nice nice nice, i give the 1st 7/10
2nd-6/10

its difficult making these things, especialy when your bored.

[Adept]

The *true* Terror Of Death
Avi: 8/10
Sig: 8/10

Alright Daichi try a new sig I just made tried something new with this one...and its not as crapy as the old ones.

[Daichi]

The *true* Terror Of Death
Avi: 8/10
Sig: 8/10

Alright Daichi try a new sig I just made tried something new with this one...and its not as crapy as the old ones.

funny. i vould like a better font....

but still. 5/10 for fun pic of Sasuke


current: wow... 7/10 for great pic


Old strawberry-L sig: THIS WAS AWESUM! cutie eyes, cool and simple BG and the strawberry 12/10




my new t.A.T.u

[Adept]

The *true* Terror Of Death
Avi: 8/10
Sig: 8/10

Alright Daichi try a new sig I just made tried something new with this one...and its not as crapy as the old ones.

funny. i vould like a better font....

but still. 5/10 for fun pic of Sasuke

Read the sig its Itachi!
new sig 8/10

[Alkaid_loves_Haseo]

Adept:
~Itachi Sig- 7/10 Great and cute pic, but I feel there could have been more done to it somehow.

~Two Kiras Sig- 8/10 Even better pic, though yet again, there's still something else that could be done with it. =/

~L Avi- 10/10 It's adorable, all goes together great and has the perfect amount of effect/exc.

Daichi:
~T.a.t.u. Sig- 9.8/10 I love it and it goes together great, but the text styling is a little plain compared to the rest of the sig.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Note about mine: As stated in my sig, I didn't make either of them. Just making that clear. ^-^
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

[Haseo{Terror of Death}]

Alkaid Avi: 6/10, It's nice, but it could always be nicer
Sig: The only perfect sig I've ever seen? 11.2/10