Haseo - Carnard Guildmaster?

Dengar · Post by **Dengar** » Sun Apr 23, 2006 6:42 pm

The guest key has a picture of the grunty, no?

Shinsou Wotan · Post by **Shinsou Wotan** » Sun Apr 23, 2006 7:36 pm

Dengar wrote:The guest key has a picture of the grunty, no?

We don't know for sure that the key features the guild's grunty. It could be a grunty that resembles whichever member created the key.

Dengar · Post by **Dengar** » Sun Apr 23, 2006 7:38 pm

I doubt a non-guild master could even give out keys.

Umbra · Post by **Umbra** » Mon Apr 24, 2006 1:33 am

Tsugasa-kun wrote:Haseo can't be the Canard Guildmaster, Thats Silabus. Aparently Haseo is the Guild Master for A guild but it looks like the Headquarters for the Twilight Brigade. Since the room looks exactly the same.

I have already stated my reasons for believing that he will become the Carnard Guildmaster, which is mainly the fact that screenshots of Carnard's @home reveal that Deathrunty resides there, rather than a Grunty that resembles Silabus.

Of course, if you do not believe that evidence, then you can not decide between those two Guilds based on anything but personal opinion. Carnard simply has the most evidence supporting it.

Dengar wrote:You know, it might be worth mentioning, that in //ROOTS, the TaN grunty resembles Tawaraya, rather than Naobi.

That is true, however, upon hearing that dialogue, I have reason to believe that Shinsou Wotan is correct. Ovan appears to have given Tabby the Key so she could give it to Haseo, however, Tawaraya gives him the Key on the spot.

Of course, even if this is a fact, and the Grunty resembles a member of the Guild rather than its master, which contradicts what we have been told, then that tells us that Haseo joined Carnard at the very least.

Dengar wrote:I doubt a non-guild master could even give out keys.

I think that the complete opposite is true, the Key is merely an invitation, it does not appear to make you a member straight away. Unless members were allowed to give Keys out, then how do you think Guilds like Tsuki no Ki or Kestrel grew to be so massive.

Kestrel is particularly supportive of my own theory, as I doubt Gabi, a rather laissez-faire Guildmaster has given out invites to five thousand players on his own.

Dengar · Post by **Dengar** » Mon Apr 24, 2006 5:43 am

I doubt that just any member can give out guest keys. And I also think that the guest key will have a picture of the guild grunty on it.

Tsugasa-kun · Post by **Tsugasa-kun** » Mon Apr 24, 2006 10:33 am

To rebuttle this Argument Tabby Gives Haseo a Key to the Twilight Brigade so it is very possible for a member to give a player a Guild Card.

Dengar · Post by **Dengar** » Mon Apr 24, 2006 5:03 pm

She got it from Ovan, that doesn't count.

Shinsou Wotan · Post by **Shinsou Wotan** » Mon Apr 24, 2006 9:08 pm

Umbra wrote:
Dengar wrote:I doubt a non-guild master could even give out keys.
I think that the complete opposite is true, the Key is merely an invitation, it does not appear to make you a member straight away. Unless members were allowed to give Keys out, then how do you think Guilds like Tsuki no Ki or Kestrel grew to be so massive.

A Guest Key, as far as I can tell, allows a nonmember to enter the guild's @HOME. Nothing more, nothing less.