Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
- shadow of skeith
- Posts: 315
- Joined: Sun Aug 10, 2008 10:06 pm
Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
Can we base Returner as canon in the G.U. storyline?
- AuraTwilight
- IT WAS OVER 9000!
- Posts: 8032
- Joined: Thu Jun 02, 2005 5:03 pm
- _Tri-edge_
- Posts: 1768
- Joined: Sun Nov 16, 2008 2:20 pm
- Location: Atlanta, GA
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
Just out of curiosity to shadow of skeith's question, how?, since this was basically the Unison of G.U.AuraTwilight wrote:It is.
- AuraTwilight
- IT WAS OVER 9000!
- Posts: 8032
- Joined: Thu Jun 02, 2005 5:03 pm
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
Unison was purely for fun. Returner actually answered plot points.
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
Obviously Returner is going to allude to things that happened in G.U., but that doesn't mean it's canon. Unison made allusions to Aura giving Kite a new bracelet at the end of IMOQ, but that didn't make Unison anymore canon.AuraTwilight wrote:Unison was purely for fun. Returner actually answered plot points.
- TheSorrow
- The Legendary Paladin
- Posts: 6587
- Joined: Sat Dec 09, 2006 9:47 pm
- Location: The Edge of Madness
- Contact:
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
But because Aura giving Kite a new bracelet also happened in the Games, while in Returner the plot points they cover aren't answered by any other media. Both were for fun, but there's a difference between explaining AIDA's future after the games and simply having a party in Net Slum.
- AuraTwilight
- IT WAS OVER 9000!
- Posts: 8032
- Joined: Thu Jun 02, 2005 5:03 pm
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
And, you know, OVAN'S RETURN FROM HIS COMA AND **** LOL. That kind've needed to be answered.
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
but partying is a story in its self who are you to say that getting drunk and some how scoring while playing an internet game isnt canon
TheSorrow wrote:But because Aura giving Kite a new bracelet also happened in the Games, while in Returner the plot points they cover aren't answered by any other media. Both were for fun, but there's a difference between explaining AIDA's future after the games and simply having a party in Net Slum.
- AuraTwilight
- IT WAS OVER 9000!
- Posts: 8032
- Joined: Thu Jun 02, 2005 5:03 pm
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
Because Sora never played the game again after waking up, and therefore can't be there for Unison, making it impossible. Not to mention that everyone was behaving out of character.but partying is a story in its self who are you to say that getting drunk and some how scoring while playing an internet game isnt canon
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
alchahole will do that to you and he didnt get comatosed until after unsion did he
AuraTwilight wrote:Because Sora never played the game again after waking up, and therefore can't be there for Unison, making it impossible. Not to mention that everyone was behaving out of character.but partying is a story in its self who are you to say that getting drunk and some how scoring while playing an internet game isnt canon
- TheSorrow
- The Legendary Paladin
- Posts: 6587
- Joined: Sat Dec 09, 2006 9:47 pm
- Location: The Edge of Madness
- Contact:
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
He went comatose right when SIGN ended, which is before the events of IMOQ, and Unison is set after those events...so yeah, not even alcohol will make something like that possible. Maybe Unison could've been possible if we simply excluded Sora and kept everything else, but it doesn't really make much sense either way.
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
Returner was much better than Unison... as soon as they started dancing in Unison I stabbed myself in the face
- AuraTwilight
- IT WAS OVER 9000!
- Posts: 8032
- Joined: Thu Jun 02, 2005 5:03 pm
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
Hey now, Unison was awesome. Shut the hell up before Tsukasa monkey dance kicks you in the face.
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
That was funny, but Silver Knight couldn't do it rightTsukasa monkey dance kicks you in the face.
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
Returner = canon.
Unison was so lame and too happy that people decided it was going to now be uncanon. TRUTH.
At least Returner was happy, in a good way. Oh and it got more points for the delicious incest end.
Unison was so lame and too happy that people decided it was going to now be uncanon. TRUTH.
At least Returner was happy, in a good way. Oh and it got more points for the delicious incest end.
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
More like wincest, amirite?ShinoBee wrote:Returner = canon.
Oh and it got more points for the delicious incest end.
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
**** YEAH SEAKING!Kerath wrote:More like wincest, amirite?ShinoBee wrote:Returner = canon.
Oh and it got more points for the delicious incest end.
I don't know, I totally saw incest with that ending. It better be canon! I expect some nii-san and loli action later yo.
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
What about the Sora AI, that Helba made at the end of Quarintine?Because Sora never played the game again after waking up, and therefore can't be there for Unison, making it impossible.
- AuraTwilight
- IT WAS OVER 9000!
- Posts: 8032
- Joined: Thu Jun 02, 2005 5:03 pm
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
One, Helba didn't make it, she found it.Keyaki wrote:What about the Sora AI, that Helba made at the end of Quarintine?Because Sora never played the game again after waking up, and therefore can't be there for Unison, making it impossible.
Two, Sora and Subaru returned as their real selves, and I don't see why Sora would be the exception, especially given that he acts different from the AI.
- Spin
- Posts: 57
- Joined: Tue Jan 22, 2008 6:01 pm
- Location: Nothing interesting ever happens in this town...
Re: Was G.U. Returner Canon or no?
I thought Returner was... weird. <.<
Not as weird as Unison, but still.
Nothing has happened to make the events of Returner impossible and the .hack peoples havn't said it isn't so, therefore it's canon for all intents and purposes.
Not as weird as Unison, but still.
Nothing has happened to make the events of Returner impossible and the .hack peoples havn't said it isn't so, therefore it's canon for all intents and purposes.