Re: Avatar And Signature Rating Topic
Posted: Sat Jul 14, 2007 11:59 pm
Someone rate please? ^^ (I already rated yours, Alkaid.)
your root town for .hack info since 2003
http://www.dothackers.net/forums/
Appreciated. For yours, I would give both the avatar and signature 9s.ShinoBee wrote:Avi: 9/10
Sig: 8.5/10
Again, appreciated. For you Alkaid, your avatar I would give a 9.5/10, and the signature (Alkaid's portion primarily) an 8.5/10, it compliments the avatar fluidly.Alkaid_loves_Haseo wrote:Akatsukami, I give you 10/10 for both. Itachi-sama rocks, and then your made them look really nice.
I wouldn't call it harsh, rather honest, and trust me, few words phase me. As artists, perceptions differ. Presentation, results, quality and analysis vary amongst a myriad of artists. I appreciate your opinions on my work. Your avatar, I would give an 8, the signature would be an 8 as well. Personally, I like the color red, for Itachi it symbolizes the death that surrounds him, obliterating his clan, and devoting his life to darkness. Not to mention the color of the Sharingan, which 98% of the time, post-ANBU, he keeps activated.Saya wrote:Avi: The avatar is really good though the red is kinda overpowering some what so I give it a 8
Sig: Seems a tad busy for me and kinda Contrasted over Itachi some I suggest using one itachi pic and make your main Focal point though the blending is good its not being used to its full effect and the text seems kinda out of place I don't think you needed the colors in the text simple white would be good here. so the sig is a 6.
Sorry that sounded alittle harsh.
Cool then you got alot of potential cause I was the same way in the beginning you take comments very well and thanks for the comments on my set.Akatsukami wrote:I wouldn't call it harsh, rather honest, and trust me, few words phase me. As artists, perceptions differ. Presentation, results, quality and analysis vary amongst a myriad of artists. I appreciate your opinions on my work. Your avatar, I would give an 8, the signature would be an 8 as well. Personally, I like the color red, for Itachi it symbolizes the death that surrounds him, obliterating his clan, and devoting his life to darkness. Not to mention the color of the Sharingan, which 98% of the time, post-ANBU, he keeps activated.Saya wrote:Avi: The avatar is really good though the red is kinda overpowering some what so I give it a 8
Sig: Seems a tad busy for me and kinda Contrasted over Itachi some I suggest using one itachi pic and make your main Focal point though the blending is good its not being used to its full effect and the text seems kinda out of place I don't think you needed the colors in the text simple white would be good here. so the sig is a 6.
Sorry that sounded alittle harsh.
I welcome all feedback, positive or negative, for it is essential for personal growth and development. I intentionally didn't go all out, just for time contraints and the fact that I didn't feel it necessary, which is why the blending isn't fully attended to, and the monochromatic color scheme is evident. In all, both the Avatar and Sig were made within 10 minutes, more time would have brought about better quality. Keeping on topic however, everyone's critique is well appreciated.Saya wrote:Cool then you got alot of potential cause I was the same way in the beginning you take comments very well and thanks for the comments on my set.Akatsukami wrote:I wouldn't call it harsh, rather honest, and trust me, few words phase me. As artists, perceptions differ. Presentation, results, quality and analysis vary amongst a myriad of artists. I appreciate your opinions on my work. Your avatar, I would give an 8, the signature would be an 8 as well. Personally, I like the color red, for Itachi it symbolizes the death that surrounds him, obliterating his clan, and devoting his life to darkness. Not to mention the color of the Sharingan, which 98% of the time, post-ANBU, he keeps activated.Saya wrote:Avi: The avatar is really good though the red is kinda overpowering some what so I give it a 8
Sig: Seems a tad busy for me and kinda Contrasted over Itachi some I suggest using one itachi pic and make your main Focal point though the blending is good its not being used to its full effect and the text seems kinda out of place I don't think you needed the colors in the text simple white would be good here. so the sig is a 6.
Sorry that sounded alittle harsh.
Akatsukami, you don't have to sound all noble-like, LOL, your work is awesome! 10/10 for both, easy. ^_^Akatsukami wrote:I welcome all feedback, positive or negative, for it is essential for personal growth and development. I intentionally didn't go all out, just for time contraints and the fact that I didn't feel it necessary, which is why the blending isn't fully attended to, and the monochromatic color scheme is evident. In all, both the Avatar and Sig were made within 10 minutes, more time would have brought about better quality. Keeping on topic however, everyone's critique is well appreciated.
Twilight Haseo wrote:Akatsukami, you don't have to sound all noble-like, LOL, your work is awesome! 10/10 for both, easy. ^_^
Your name's cool too, almost sounds like a Japanese deity, aMatsukami.